Daily Doc: TI, Sep 20, 1979: Attack on Allstate/Sears
Daily Doc: Attack on Allstate/Sears
Title: Re: Allstate Life's Healthy American Plan
TI, Sep 20, 1979
Bates #: TIMN0037155/7158
March 11, 2000
Today's document shows more of the theme of the tobacco industry's pattern of retribution against businesses supportive tobacco-free lifestyles. Documents show that this behavior has been going on for decades, and pervaded many areas of business. The tobacco industry proved to be quite "bully on the block."
In 1979, Allstate Insurance/Sears introduced its "Healthy American Plan," a life insurance plan that included non-smoker discounts. Allstate began advertising the discount as a prominent feature of their new plan. The tobacco industry got mad and started encouraging businesses to boycott Allstate/Sears.
At the same time, the Tobacco Institute was running a series of "pro-smoking" ads stressing familiar TI themes like "reasonable accommodation" for smokers, "individualism," and "Freedom of choice is the best choice."
This irony was not lost on Allstate's Senior Vice President and General Counsel, Robert Seilor, who noticed that while the TI was touting "free choice is the best choice," they would quickly limit peoples' choice to select a particular insurance plan. He also noted that while the TI was promoting "accommodation," they were at the same time loathe to accommodate an insurance plan based on actuarial assessment of the costs of the non-smoking lifestyle. With these points in mind, Seilor wrote the following letter to the Tobacco Institute. In addition to sounding like a mother trying to reason with an angry child, Seilor wisely employed the strategy of appealing to the tobacco industry's self-interest.
CITATION
Title: Re: Allstate Life's Healthy American Plan
Type of Document: Letter
Author: Robert S. Seller, Senior Corporate Vice President, Secretary and General Counsel, Allstate Life Insurance Company
Recipient: Mr. Kirk Wayne, President, "Tobacco Associates"
Date: 19790920
Site: Tobacco Institute Document Site
Page Count: 4
Bates No. TIMN0037155/7158
URL: (of all pages) http://www.tobaccoinstitute.com/getallimg.asp?DOCID=TIMN0037155/7158
URL of first page (for easy printing, view and print page by page): http://www.tobaccoinstitute.com/getimg.asp?pgno=0&start=0&bool=TIMN0037155&docid=TIMN0037155/7158&docnum=1
QUOTES
Mr. Kirk Wayne, President
Tobacco Associates
1101 7th Street NW
Washington, DC 20036
RE: Allstate Life's Healthy American Plan
Dear Sir,
As you know, representatives of Allstate Life have met with the Tobacco Institute...in response to the tobacco industry's objection to our non-smoker discount, which is a feature of the above-captioned plan. We did so in an effort to convince the tobacco industry that our non-smoker discount and, in particular, our advertising of that discount, was neither anti-smoker not an attack upon the tobacco industry...
...Mr. Yeargin [managing director of the Tobacco Institute] stated that he would continue his campaign against Allstate and Sears, notwithstanding the essentially inoffensive nature of our commercial. He indicated that the Allstate commercial was the "straw that broke the camel's back" and evidenced extreme frustration at the industry's inability to respond to our ads on TV. It is Mr. Yeargin's reaction which prompts, this letter.
Allstate understands the factors which have promulgated your action and your concern for the future of the industry. However, we do not believe that the campaign against Allstate and Sears is well-advised or in the long-range best interests of the [tobacco] industry.
...Your objectives and tactics will be considered by most people, including many in government, as completely contradictory to the Tobacco Institute's advertisements. Those ads make the following points:
1.. They seek "sensible accommodation" between smokers and non-smokers. Your campaign will not be viewed as consistent with that objective. It will be viewed as an anti-non-smoker campaign.
2. Anti-smokers ... desire to force others to comply with their special prejudices. Your campaign against Allstate and Sears will probably be viewed as an effort to enforce your "special prejudices" against others.
3. "Freedom of choice is the best choice." How will non-smokers be apprised of the existence of a discount on life insurance if you seek to "penalize" Allstate or Sears for advertising the existence of the discount? That hardly gives non-smokers any choice at all.
Basically, your...objection appears to be that we are discriminating against smokers....Our rating approach...seek(s) to make the rate fit the mortality experience of the class of risk, i.e. the non-smoker. Credible statistical evidence exists to support the discount. Certainly smokers will pay a slightly higher rate...(approximately 3% for this plan of insurance only). While that is a distinction between the two classes of risks, it is not unfairly discriminatory.
Allstate has no desire to make enemies in the marketplace....The publicity which your efforts are generating (judging by the number of interviews I have granted in the last week) is certain to come to the attention of the national cancer and heart associations as well as the HEW and "anti-smokers" organizations. They will probably use this activity against you in an effort to destroy your factual credibility, since your actions are so contradictory to the Tobacco Institute's own ad. In addition, non-smokers could very well see a backlash or some conversions to the ranks of anti-smokers.
We appreciate that this is an emotional subject for your industry. However, may we respectfully appeal to your objectivity and your self-interest and ask that you reconsider the decision to continue taking action against Allstate and Sears...
...Thank you for considering our request....
Very Truly Yours,
Robert S. Seiler
[Senior Vice President, Secretary and General Council, Allstate Life Insurance Company]
This service is brought to you by the American Lung Association of Colorado ( http://www.alacolo.org/) and Smokescreen ( http://www.smokescreen.org)
To join Doc-Alert, go to http://tobaccodocuments.org/, scroll down to the bottom of the page, enter your email address in the box marked "Daily Document Newsletter," and click *subscribe.*
Visit the Daily Document Archives at http://www.smokescreen.org/list/viewmsgs.cfm?id=66.
Anne Landman, Regional Program Coordinator
American Lung Association of Colorado, West Region Office
Grand Junction, CO
(970) 245-2120
afoxland@gj.net
***********************
Go To: Tobacco BBS HomePage / Resources Page / Health Page / Documents Page / Culture Page / Activism Page
***********************
END OF DOCUMENT