Tobacco.org

• CLEARY v. PHILIP MORRIS, INC.  

Brian Cleary and Rita Burke, representing a putative class, have sued several tobacco companies and tobacco-related entities. This case was filed in state court in 1998. Defendant Lorillard Tobacco Co. removed it to this Court after plaintiffs filed a third amended complaint on March 3, 2009. In their third amended complaint, plaintiffs make several claims against the defendants on behalf of Illinois residents. Among other claims, plaintiffs allege that defendants deceptively marketed "low tar," "light," and "ultra light" cigarettes as being safer than regular cigarettes, although they were equally dangerous. Defendants have moved for judgment on the pleadings with respect to these claims on the ground that they are time-barred. For the following reasons, the Court grants the motion as to the defendants other than Philip Morris but defers ruling as to Philip Morris. . . .

For the foregoing reasons, the Court grants defendants' motion for judgment on the pleadings concerning Count 3 of the third amended complaint [docket no. 85] as to all defendants other than Philip Morris. The Court directs Philip Morris to show cause, by no later than September 21, 2009, why the Court should not vacate the state court's interlocutory order dismissing the light cigarettes claim. Pending ruling on that matter, the Court defers consideration of whether the Marlboro Lights claims in the third amended complaint relate back to the date the plaintiffs filed the first amended complaint. The case is set for a status hearing on September 23, 2009 at 9:30 a.m.

Jump to full article »