[Headlines Only] [Top Stories Only]
Categories
· Health/Science
· Smokefree Policies
· Cardio-vascular
· Op-Ed
non-USA, by Country
· UK-Scotland

SULUM: Scottish Smoking Ban Study Leads to Huge Drop in Journalistic Credibility 

Hit & Run
Jump to full article: Reason Magazine, 2007-11-21
Author: Jacob Sullum

Intro:

Two months ago, a study reporting that the imposition of Scotland's smoking ban had been followed by a 17 percent drop in hospital admissions for heart attacks prompted credulous headlines like these: . . . .

Now it turns out that the complete admissions data for the year following the ban show a drop less than half as big as the one claimed in the study and in all those news stories. And as Michael Blastland shows in a recent BBC News article, the 8 percent drop may simply be part of a long-term trend:

Jump to full article »