Tobacco News:

Lawsuits: Bowles
RSS: http://tobacco.org/newsfeed/lawsuit/bowles.rss
Choose type:
Search Term(s):
[Headlines Only] [Top Stories Only]
Bowles
[1 - 1 of 1]
Categories
· Lawsuits
non-USA, by Country
· Australia
Lawsuits
· Bowles

BOWLES v. CANTON PTY LTD (trading as TIEN TIEN CAFÉ BAR) DECISION OF MAGISTRATES’ COURT OF VICTORIA – 13 SEPTEMBER 2000 

Jump to full article: Smokescreen Action Network, 2000-10-24

Intro:

The plaintiff, Andrea Bowles, an asthmatic, attended the Tien Tien restaurant in August 1998. Another member of her party had earlier made a telephone reservation, stipulating that their table was to be in the non-smoking section of the restaurant.

Ms Bowles and her party were seated at a table on the border between the smoking and non-smoking areas of the restaurant, as designated that evening. Between 10 and 12 people were smoking within about 2 metres of where Ms Bowles was sitting. . .

The Magistrate held that the evidence “establishes a clear causal connection between the restaurant conditions and the illness of the plaintiff over the following six to eight weeks”. He found the restaurant liable on three separate grounds – breach of contract; breach of duty of care in negligence; and occupiers liability. He reduced the award of damages by 30% for contributory negligence by Ms Bowles.

Jump to full article »